UCEPROTECT blacklists innocent sites by ASN, then charges $30/month to whitelist them
Tell HN: Uceprotect is extorting website owners
A site owner discovered their IP was blocked by Orange's security filters because UCEPROTECT Level 3 lists all of ASN 14061 (DigitalOcean) by reputation, not individual wrongdoing. Other major hosting providers' ASNs are also listed. UCEPROTECT offers whitelisting for about $30/month or $108/year, which the author calls extortion after 20 years in the industry.
Honestly, in my 20-year career, this is the first time I've seen a blacklist misbehave this badly and ask for money when there's clearly been no wrongdoing.
- someonebaggy
All of the spam blocklists are like this.
At one time quite recently, Cloudflare was on Spamhaus's "Don't Route Or Peer" list. Imagine where the world would be if anyone cared about that list.
But if an entire ISP is blocking you based on UCEPROTECT, which is designed for email spam filters - are you sure? An ISP that blocked all of DO would get so many complaints and be open to so much legal liability. Usually these are only used for email filtering.
- john_strinlai
the more ive looked at this uceprotect site, the more i see how unhinged they are.
for example: "People with a brain would simply fix their systems after getting listed for abuse. Stupid losers are different." http://www.uceprotect.org/cart00neys/index.html
or
"This time, however, we have a premiere: A Woman. Actually, it reads more like a brat than a woman [...] If we were as emotional as you are and report you to our authorities, the handcuffs might click the next time you move your ass off the British Isles. [...] This means that they have heared that bullshit you spammed to them at times when you still slipped across the floor with your shit diaper. :-) [...]
Grow up and also try to grow a brain before you make a fool out of yourself, again next time.
Claus von Wolfhausen
Technical Director" http://www.uceprotect.org/cart00neys/2021-001.html
their main page has an iamverybadass quote, too: "WARNING: Do not play around here. You have no idea who we really are, and what will happen to you!"
- mrmattyboy
The uceprotect Level 3 page clearly says using the list will cause collateral damage and should only use as an indicator as part of a spam score, not to act purely on it.
So, yes, if a service provider is known for having a lot of spam coming from it, it makes sense to be on there. They're not saying every IP is bad, they're literally stating the opposite (which seems fair).
So, if Orange are blocking purely based on it, not only are they using a spam filter as a DNS query/web filter (given uceprotect seems to flag based on mail spam traps based detections etc.) and ignoring their documentation (which says it shouldn't be used to block on it's own).
- JohnMakin
DigitalOcean has been on their list for a while, they say something like “if you don’t want to be flagged as spam, dont host on a site that hosts spammers” which is pretty ridiculous given every cloud platform does
- 5kyl4b
Check this...