ChatGPT Is Forging New Yorker Cartoonists' Signatures on AI-Generated Cartoons

ChatGPT is adding real cartoonists' signatures to fake New Yorker cartoons

ChatGPT Is Forging New Yorker Cartoonists' Signatures on AI-Generated Cartoons

OpenAI's ChatGPT has been generating New Yorker-style cartoons signed with the real pen names of more than 15 of the magazine's cartoonists, including Emily Flake and Jason Adam Katzenstein, without permission. The signatures, which cartoonists call certificates of authenticity, are being reproduced on AI slop. OpenAI says it is addressing the issue, but the signatures persist.

I'm not a territorial person, but my name is my name. It felt very much like a violation of my personhood.
  1. rwmj

    A practical step is cartoonists should register their name/signature as a trademark. Arguably they should have been doing this before AI came along, but definitely they should do it now. Registration makes enforcement easier.

  2. Isamu

    The part of the AI generating the mashup doesn’t really understand what the signature means, or how it may be interpreted, it’s just a visual part of a New Yorker cartoon. Elsewhere in ChatGPT there is plenty of information about signatures and what they mean, and what plagiarism is.

    It’s not organized like a human brain, it shouldn’t be surprising that unusual results occur. They are approximating human intelligence from a different angle. It’s interesting to see the improvements in areas like this that require introspection that isn’t fully wired up yet.

    [edit] I should add that a human making a New Yorker cartoon is extremely iterative and introspective. Current generative AI is meant to push it out, and you can do the iteration and introspection yourself.

  3. gwern

    This has been a perennial problem with my own generated comics with both Nano Banana Pro and ChatGPT (all generations). I often have to put in an extra edit to erase the false signature. It is annoying and I'm unsurprised most users don't bother.

  4. jameson

    I'm certain if I drew a cartoon and used the signature that looks just like a real cartoonists', I would get sued and liable for the damage.

    The same should apply to LLM vendors.

  5. dormento

    The copyright washing machine strikes again.

  6. WD-42

    Engineering manager at my company put a comic at the end of our sprint demo that was signed bloper. Except it wasn’t funny at all, and kind of weird. I asked him, sure enough it was ChatGPT and he didn’t notice the signature.

  7. ThrowawayR2

    Nice. This demolishes the "LLMs can reason" (but not enough to avoid this sort of basic error) and "humans make mistakes too" (not like this) talking points from the LLM promoters.

  8. zahlman

    Of course it does this. The training data is full of examples that associate e.g. "New Yorker-style cartoon" with Loper's signature in the corner, because Loper's signature is in the corner of a lot of them. There's nothing to make it treat the signature as anything special by default; that would have to be trained in explicitly.

    One would hope that the person prompting ChatGPT would notice this sort of thing and do something about it before sharing it publicly, out of a genuine desire not to cause confusion etc. But I guess that's way more personal responsibility than we can expect average people to take on nowadays.

  9. serf

    this is trivial to reproduce ever since early stable diffusion models, it's not really an oai exclusive issue.

    for example if you ask any of these models (just about any image-gen) to produce Japanese ukiyo-e art they will almost always produce it with a hanko[0] that has been seen a lot in historical art pieces, usually having nothing to do with the era or style of the replica but seen so often in 'Japanese artwork' that it's just permanently tokenized into it as a defining characteristic.

    [0]: https://theartofzen.org/the-hanko-in-japanese-art-and-ukiyo-...

  10. thih9

    I wish the article's original title was: "OpenAI is adding real cartoonists' signatures to fake New Yorker cartoons", and followed with relevant legal consequences.

More from this day

2026-10-05