House members' stock picks underperformed the market, a study of 8,900 trades finds

Do House members' stock trades beat the market? A test of 8,900 trades

Researchers tracked 8,941 stock trades disclosed by 99 House members, measuring returns from both the trade date and the day each filing went public. Against the equal-weighted S&P 500, the median purchase lost 2.4% over six months, and the median stock members sold lost 1.7% — what they bought did no better than what they sold. No group of purchases, by party, size, account, or disclosure delay, clearly beat the index.

If members knew something, the stocks they bought should do better than the stocks they sold.
  1. thriving_earthw

    If you want stock trading by congressional representatives (or government officials more broadly) to be banned, I don't think it matters whether they actually beat the market.

    The best argument against stock trading is that even the appearance or potential for impropriety of this kind violates the public trust and undermines faith in our governing institutions.

    Being an elected official should come with borderline draconian limits on how you are allowed to spend your money.

  2. zug_zug

    Median performance? That's not a correct calculation.

    To calculate proper stock returns you need weighted mean. Often in stocks you have a few outliers that give the vast majority of your profit.

    I don't know if this is ignorance, but from a methodological standpoint this seems like an attempt to deceive or hide data.

  3. ummonk

    If you only measure median performance as this is doing, do any group of individuals' stock trades beat the market? I'd expect most of the alpha to come not from the median transaction but from a few well timed buys or sales.

  4. cm2187

    Not sure the average representative is the right benchmark, that's not the real insiders. The real insiders would be in the upper ranks of congress, with prominent seats in commissions, part of security briefings, and with front row in draft legislations (the average representative first discovers the proposed new law when a 7000 pages final version is dropped on their desk 20 minutes before the vote).

  5. somid3

    I remember reading they don't disclose the exact date and hour of the purchase and sale, so intra-day trading or tight timeline trades are impossible to measure, is that correct?

  6. matteoraso

    Yeah, I've looked at the net worth of various congressmen recently, and most of the wealthy members were wealthy from before politics. Americans complain about their politicians only getting into the career to get rich, but that doesn't seem to be true. In fact, it's kind of shocking how little they get paid, considering they run one of the most powerful countries in the world. This is even more true at the state level.

  7. somid3

    If anyone wants to analyze the raw data using R or AI or whatever, you can find it here:

    https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1PD84w61HrL1a6lyAMGCO...

    I'm having tons of fund.

  8. bawana

    I think politicians should be paid according to their performance - how well their constituents are doing. If the McDonald's index shows people are getting relatively poorer, politicians' pay should adjusted accordingly.

More from this day

2026-11-15