Judge Lets DRAM Price-Fixing Suit Against Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron Proceed
Court denies motion to dismiss DRAM price fixing case

A federal judge in California refused to dismiss an antitrust class action accusing Samsung, SK Hynix and Micron—which together hold over 91% of global DRAM revenue—of cutting production, shifting capacity to AI-focused HBM memory and exiting DDR3 and DDR4 lines in lockstep. The court rejected the defendants' argument that the suit merely repeats a 2016–2018 case the Ninth Circuit threw out, finding the alleged conduct distinct. Seventeen consumers and small businesses brought the suit.
The crux of the parties' arguments is whether, as Defendants contend, this case is a rerun of In re Dynamic Random Access Memory (DRAM) Indirect Purchaser Antitrust Litig., in which the Ninth Circuit affirmed dismissal of claims against these same Defendants based on a 2016–2018 supply restriction. The Court finds that it is not, and DENIES Defendants' motion to dismiss.
- SubiculumCode
If they are price fixing, eff them.
Finally secure a research grant and had budgeted money for a new compute workstation and the RAM prices are killing my budget, because I'd love to get at least 256 GB of RAM and that's 4-5 grand now. Ridiculous, especially since I'd like to have a GPU in it with at least 32Gb of VRAM for medical image model training, so that is also like 4-5 grand too.
Do I wait two years and hope, or pay, isthe question I keep asking myself.
- PeterStuer
It's a 3 way prisoners dilemma market where the prisoners have been caught explicitly colluding before. Now they do not need explicit colluding anymore as the pattern and outcome has been established already and the "jail" is as good as closed to new entrants. Clearly the expected "market" is not working in this niche, so something will have to be done about it.
- bloomingeek
Having read most of the posts for this subject, I got to thinking: wouldn't it be cool and beneficial to the HN community, if we tried to anticipate equipment price spikes? We tend to be electronic parts focused, so why not post trends as we see them.
Example: I, like I'm sure others did, saw the M.2 SSD prices starting to rise. Even though I didn't see the data center build up coming, I bought a small supply of SSDs. Unfortunately I didn't realize the future memory situation!
If this isn't cool with the Hacker News bylaws, I withdraw this idea :)
- bparsons
I think there is a greater argument that points to hoarding of the global supply of these components by three or four cloud companies, which in turn forces consumers to rent their services.
- sysguest
idk going with DDR3/4/5 upgrades are really makes me doubt the whole argument...
those upgrades ARE ACTUAL UPGRADES, and if exiting ddr4 helps on producing more ddr5, why not?
(and the cheap chinese makers can produce plenty of those ddr4 chips, so it's NOT that "monopoly destroying the market" scenario)
- ketzu
I am curious to see what will be uncovered in the trial. I know way too little of the market and tech involved to come to a conclusion (beyond anything motivated from wanting cheaper memory again).
Nearly everything could have a non-colluding explanation depending on the tech and market. (for example I would be skeptical to build up extremly expensive production if i follow the widespread belief that Ai is a huge bubble)
However, collusion is not magically out of the question with previous instances and some unexplained indicators. (which imo is what this dismissal means)
- born-jre
Not exactly related but I was thinking why don’t gov make rule like 40% of DRAM production has to be allocated for consumer electronics sectors but no AI regulation, wonder that would make compute distributed and no chicken and chicken man situation
- badgersnake
Lock them up and throw away the key, ideally with the serial killers.