Nvidia Reportedly Inflated GPU Prices Through Circular Financing Deals
Nvidia deliberately kept GPU prices high through circular financing deals

A Wall Street Journal profile of interim CEO Colette Kress claims Nvidia financed its own customers to absorb an oversupply of TSMC wafers and keep GPU prices high. Deals with cloud providers and OpenAI reportedly included a $250 billion backstop, while GeForce cards now sell above 160% of MSRP. Kress voiced concerns about the scale of the arrangements; Jensen Huang pushed ahead anyway, then berated her as "a deer in headlights" when the chip glut hit.
At a Berlin conference, the former CEO told major clients a story about a busy Japanese soup vendor who refused to give him a second serving after he had waited in a long line, saying the vendor had too many customers and not enough soup.
- hadlock
If the price of the RTX 6000 (96gb blackwell gpu) drops to $2000 (original MSRP $8000, currently $16,000 usd due to "scarcity") then, all of a sudden, "we have ai at home" becomes real and why would you ever pay for a subscription for your company/family when you can run Qwen Flash Next (which runs great on consumer GPU via software like Strata) forever for free?
Engineering types and power users need not apply,but For Everyone Else, the "normies", Qwen Flash Next is probably "640k is enough for anyone" territory.
IPO, valuation etc depend heavily on frontier, or "good enough" AI to need to run on commercial grade GPUs. If Qwen Flash Next is good enough and runs on a $2000 GPU, why would you pay $20/30/100/200 per month in perpetuity?
I wouldn't pick Qwen Flash Next to add kernel namespacing and cgroups v2 to my custom OS kernel, but it will happily implement the Plan.md that Fable 5.2 wrote for a dollar.
- k0morebi
Not speaking about the possible knowledge of smuggling in contravention of law, marital infidelity, and possibility getting mixed up with an intelligence agent, but I don't see the circular financing thing as a problem. Maybe I'm misinformed.
But weren't they were investing money in companies to help them grow and in turn buy more of their product. Of course Nvidia wants to stimulate demand of their product. I don't think this was nefarious. There is no free lunch, the risk of them never getting that money back is real with a lot of these pie in the sky AI companies. How is this anticompetitive? It's all of these SPVs that meta, google, and others are using that I think needs to be investigated and punished by wall street.
If you think that's wrong, USE YOUR WORDS, I'm open to reason. Down voting with no response or making jeers is not effective communication.
- lizknope
We had a huge thread about this yesterday
Nvidia allegedly engineered scarcity by funding AI startups to buy its GPUs (techpowerup.com)
- stephc_int13
Jensen Huang made mistakes that gave opportunities to his enemies. But the bigger mistake was his incredible greed, he should have been a happy supplier of an extremely valuable product, and accept competition and that his quasi-monopoly was only transient. But he wanted the entire cake for himself.
Greed and hubris. I think the turbulences will be painful to some, especially those who counted on Nvidia stock to finance their retirement.
But, big picture, this is good news.
- justauserid
These days we think of these astronomical price rises only from the angle of AI usage, while it has left a much starker and detrimental mark on general personal computing space. I am not sure Huang ever came across as a saint, or seemed remotely so, even before this fiasco. Something tells me he yet comes out of it mostly unscathed in the longer run. They always do. This collusion has been clear, blatant, and went sadly unquestioned.
- wqnt
Most demand side data points (high GPU rent price, comments from all major cloud providers and model inference providers) show that available compute is in shortage. The AI compute demand is probably real and not manufactured.
It looks like NVIDIA does these deals to screw its competitors: it takes out key supply so Google/Amazon/AMD can't get them, and it provide some financing to neoclouds so these data centers use NVIDIA chips instead of running AMD/TPU/trainium. These tactics are aggressive and anti-competitive, but the problem is different from creating phantom demand.
- liendolucas
Can someone explain why is so hard to break away from CUDA and why companies like Intel or AMD can't release a competing product? What it really can't fit in my mind is the reliance of just Nvidia for this boom... With all the expertise and knowledge that both Intel and AMD have I can't see why is so difficult for them to have at least a second option to Nvidia.
- pocketlim
There was a huge thread about this yesterday.
Please have a read at this before you start yammering