A father raises his daughters as native Esperanto speakers, and wonders why
Bilingualism and Denaskuleco
Parker Adey has spoken Esperanto to his daughter Mira since birth, making her one of only a few thousand native speakers, or denaskuloj, worldwide. Her younger sister Mabel has had far less exposure. Adey admits French would make more practical sense in Canada, but he wants his kids bilingual, aware of life in a linguistic minority, and able to join Esperanto gatherings.
I was fluent in English and Esperanto, I wanted Mira to be bilingual, and so I taught her Esperanto.
- PowerElectronix
I don't wanna preach how to raise children, but picking esperanto as a second language to teach the kids is going to be a very uphill battle.
It's not the native language of anyone, especially in the family so they are not going to be as exposed to it as one would in a family with a non- english native. And then there's no esperanto anywhere else so they are going to learn quickly they don't need it at all except for when daddy says something in esperanto.
- jareklupinski
growing up bilingual is much easier when your immediate family / community speak the "first language"
now that im surrounded by Americans, its much harder to justify the mental load of teaching a non-scholastic second language when there is no community to reinforce what youve learned beyond rote learning exercises. im not convinced multiple languages made me smarter either...
- joshdavham
Given that the parents aren’t native Esperanto speakers themselves, would this make the version of Esperanto that the children speak a sort of Creole?