AI companies are parasites
Cory Dransfeldt argues that AI companies operate as parasites on society: they scrape the internet without compensation, train models on stolen data, sell metered access, and repeat until the host is killed. The old bargain of traffic for indexing is gone, replaced by scrapers that overload infrastructure, collapse clickthroughs, and destroy communities. Licensing deals like Reddit's still depend on human-generated data from flagging communities. Data centers bring pollution, higher utility rates, and few lasting jobs. The result: stilted prose, derivative images, and incomprehensible code.
Scrape the whole of the internet, destroy books, siphon everything they can from whoever they can without compensation, and call it fair use.
- discreteevent
Watch the parasites swarm all over this thread. (It's been flagged already). The host (HN) is at the point of suffocation.
- senko
The post is a zero-information personal rant (good for him/her!), impossible to comment on without violating at least half of the HN guidelines[0].
[0] literally; even this comment violates a few
- gridspy
Bear in mind that like many toxic blooms, once the investment hysteria feeding them dies out they will die also.
- Companies using investment funds to play the Ai Agent lottery will run out of funds
- Less tokens will be demanded, causing AI companies to raise prices to pay for overheads
- Bubble pops.
- altmanaltman
I mean, if you really extend that line of thinking, human beings are parasites in general. We are just sucking up all the resources to make more Walmarts and McDonald's. It would then be fair to say that humans should be dislodged from the earth and should never have attached to it in the first place. However, that would be a simplistic and rather naive view of how society works and does not have a solid moral standing behind the argument other than an emotional appeal: "THE ROBOTS ARE STEALING OUR HUMANITY!!!"
Rather, why not go deeper? Why not look at the world around you and see what incentives we've built up that allow us to plow trillions of dollars into this without a second thought. We've seen the bust cycles happen and yet here we are: going all-in on a potential technology that might/might not work out as we are hoping it will. If it truly works out as these companies are hoping then it'll be an economic disaster. If it doesn't work as these companies are hoping then it'll be an economic disaster.
Yet the Darios and Altmans of the world always find a way.
- simianwords
I find it sad that people don't generally think about non zero sum possibilities.
I think it comes from a misreading of Marx because Marx considers value coming from Labor which is purely zero sum.
In my bubble within friends and family, practically everyone uses AI and has fun using it and gets value out of it.