Tufte's Data-Ink Ratio: Why Chasing 100% Is a Mistake

Demystifying Tufte's data-ink ratio

Edward Tufte's data-ink ratio measures how much of a chart's ink actually shows data. This interactive guide takes apart a cluttered bar chart step by step, showing how the ratio rises from 3.4% to 9.0% as you erase non-data ink. But pushing to 100% strips away titles and labels, losing information. The lesson: keep ink that helps readers, cut the rest.

It only compares the ink that's left, so it can't see what's missing.
  1. gjm11

    I think the idea that a bar chart is usually improved by narrowing its bars while keeping them in the same positions is pretty silly. Yes, the article does say that one can take it too far, but I think that's the wrong framing. It's not that using less ink is good, but sometimes if you take that too far then it competes with visual clarity. Visual clarity is always the goal; sometimes clearer designs have more non-data ink, sometimes less; many designs are too busy so "less non-data ink" is usually good, but not always.

    Tufte's "data-ink ratio" is a pretty good heuristic, but e.g. it would probably become a better match for actual visual clarity if what you counted wasn't "amount of ink" but something that measures spatial change in ink. It's the transitions that feel like noise, much more than patches of constant colour. But "data-ink ratio" is easier to say and easier to read than "ratio of integral of norm of gradient of colour".

    Also, I think this sort of graph is better with very light gridlines than with no gridlines, though I think Tufte would disagree.

    Also also, in Tufte's book, immediately before the section about "data-ink" there is an copy of a graph drawn by Playfair showing a country's balance of trade over time. Tufte gives it as an example of a good informational graphic. You can see it at https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/William_Playfair#/media/File:P... if you like. This graph uses shading to indicate which direction the balance of trade goes in; that informati […]

  2. quietbritishjim

    I've always hated the data-ink ratio metric. It's totally invalid.

    The proof of this is right there in one of the examples in The Visual Display of Quantitative Information.

    He shows an example where the axes of a scatter chart are shortened to the range of the data in each direction. This is a data-ink win-win! You get more information (the range of the data, at a glance), and it doesn't matter how little importance that is because you also have less ink!

    But of course it actually looks terrible. To think otherwise, you have to be so busy thinking about metrics that you ignore your eyes. The axes no longer overlap in the corner, so the whole thing looks like a soup of visual fragments rather than a single cohesive thing.

    Imagine you had several of these on a page side by side. It would be far harder to visually focus on one for a moment, because the fragments of different subfigures would be one big visual soup.

    The solution is to put boxes around them (they don't have to be big thick black boxes, just something to visually separate the different things). But of course Tufte hates boxes. They add ink for no information content.

    It's just bad science. Or brains don't process black pixels, one at a time, spending mental energy on each one. They see different visual fragments, having been heavily pre-processed by the CNN in our optic nerves before reaching our frontal contexts. The thing you actually need to minimise is visual complexity. Often, adding ink (for no information) […]

  3. jmkd

    Despite knowing the correct answer to the question in the first section, the diabolical wording on it absolutely threw me:

    "Erase the shaded background: does the share of ink that shows the five numbers go up, down, or stay the same?"

    In the spirit of the project, try asking me instead,

    "Remove the shaded background: is the amount of ink now left on the chart more useful, less useful or the same as before?"

    Damn...even that was hard to write.

  4. wiredfool

    This isn't a great example, because they're effectively using a chart to show a handful of data points. The key with the data/ink ratio is to densify the amount of data shown so that the ink that is used can show additional dimensions or statistics -- such as using a 2 dimensional plot, turning the axes into box plot equivalents, or other relationships.

  5. hanibrel

    There should be a similar metric for information density in an article. This one is so repetitive that it's hard to keep reading since the whole point was already contained in the first section. The rest keeps just repeating again and again. Too bad the slop density is off the charts on this one.

More from this day

2026-10-05