AI Came for the Coders. Understanding Why Tells Us Who's Next

Software engineering is the most gradeable work humans have ever produced: code compiles or it doesn't, tests pass or fail, and machines can check the results in seconds. That, not any mystical notion of 'human' work, is what makes a job vulnerable to AI. The real predictor is a two-part test—how easily a task can be automatically graded and how objectively its value can be agreed upon. Poetry and parenting score high on value but resist grading; commercial art and copywriting score high on both and are already being automated. The lesson for knowledge workers: AI produces deliverables, people achieve outcomes.
There will never be a compiler that can check for bugs in your poem.
- mattkenefick
I think it most publicly came for coders, but has been quietly taking over everyone else without them knowing it.
- datadrivenangel
AI for coders is somewhat analogous to a backhoe or automated welding machine. An operator can do a lot more work than before, but setting it up to do that work correctly and safely still takes skill.
This however will put salary pressure on the people who were simply digging holes or welding beads without being as involved in the planning and design work. Time to remember that we can't forget the business part!
- drdaeman
> there will never be a compiler that can check for bugs in your poem.
Why not? There always were and will be artists who would want to crack their art open, analyze it, understand how it works, and synthesize new art intently, engineering it. And no amount of sacralization of that air of mystery around art will stop that from happening. I’m absolutely sure there will be machines that analyze poetry, model readers/listeners (contemporary or predicted future audiences), and find “bugs” as mismatches between the intended and modeled effects.
And the art won’t be any tiniest bit less enjoyable. Well, unless present-day adtech will survive and abuse it all.
- danpalmer
Software Engineering is objectively measurable, but needs a different objective measurement (test, benchmark, etc) for each part, feature, behaviour, etc. This is part of why I don't think it's going away as a discipline, although I agree it'll change very significantly.
The areas hit hardest are going to be those where one person can specify the objective once, and then value can be delivered ongoing from that. Data labelling, categorisation, maybe things like QA. Arguably things like autonomous driving.
- jimbobbam
Great article. I agree with the sediment entirely.
Still though, we have major problems that need solving. Broken infrastructure, rising tides, deforestation, loss of bio diversity. It will take people to stop looking at the box, and start looking at the problems that need fixing.