GNU Emacs Maintainers Say They'd Accept Code Made by Slaves, and One Advocate Has Had Enough

When Free Software Isn't Free Enough

A mailing list thread on emacs-devel about whether GNU Emacs should accept LLM-generated contributions turned into a bigger argument about the limits of free software. Asked whether the project would take a technically correct patch produced by forced labor, maintainer Eli Zaretskii answered that it must, since only code quality matters. The author, a longtime free software advocate, argues that freedom confined to the programmer-and-code relationship is too narrow.

A freedom that only reaches people who already have the privilege of reading source code is a narrow freedom.
  1. hungryhobbit

    >The full case against LLMs — how they’re built on unconsented labor, sold through hype, and coercively pushed onto workers — deserves its own post, which I’ll link here once I publish it.

    I don't dispute that the frontier LLM companies stole vast amounts of intellectual property ... like many orders of magnitude more IP than people who are spending years in jail for piracy. That's indisputable.

    But when you start equating piracy (I'm reading your book without paying for it) to SLAVERY (enforced labor) ... that's just so completely ridiculous that I find it difficult to take anything this guy writes seriously.

  2. oska

    When (Theravada) Buddhist monks go out each morning to accept food donations (Dānasantuṭṭhi) from the laity, they do not exclude donations from anyone

    In the Pali Canon, the Buddha accepted alms from murderers, thieves and courtesans

    Monks follow this example in practising Upekkha, impartiality

    (Of course, if the food is bad or inedible they will not consume it but the source of the donation, and how the giver was able to obtain the food donated, is not considered)

  3. skybrian

    > Freedom for users, not just programmers. Source code access means little if you can’t read it. Real software freedom has to include usability, accessibility, documentation, and support in the languages people actually speak.

    Programming has gotten much more accessible with LLMs. This will eventually result in more user freedom in practice, once forking free software becomes the norm for end users. But custom software needs to be managed, so we will need hosting services and software installers that make finding, downloading, and customizing apps easy.

  4. untilted

    Relevant comment from Stefan Monnier (former emacs maintainer) on emacs-devel:

    > The issue I have with this is that it moves the goal from "defend Free Software" to "defend against generative AI". The Free Software movement's goals are largely aligned with many other social movements, yet to avoid fragmenting our community, the FSF has been very careful to try and stick to software freedom (and let individual members combine this with any other issue they like). I'd rather leave the fight against slop to other groups, even if there might be a lot of overlap between that group and ours.

    https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/emacs-devel/2026-10/msg00...

  5. palata

    I don't have a strong opinion, but I wanted to say two things:

    1. If Free Software must be ethical and therefore refuse contributions by LLMs, should Free Software refuse contributions made on hardware that was itself made of components that were not ethically-sourced? Should contributors prove that their laptop is made of ethically-sourced materials? Good luck with that, I guess?

    2. Now that LLMs are there and are undeniably multipliers, isn't that an opportunity for Free Software? Reverse engineering proprietary firmwares used to take years, now LLMs make that a lot faster. In a way, is it bad to "use the weapon of the enemy in the fight against themselves"? I would think that this is debatable?

More from this day

2026-11-18