An AI audited an entire physics field and found 872 errors—most still being copied

I had AI read my field

Casey Handmer, a Caltech-trained astrophysicist, used AI to read 158,059 papers and 554,670 citations in theoretical astrophysics. Every paper with full text was screened, and 659 of the most-cited were recomputed line by line. The audit uncovered 872 verified errors in 433 papers; 367 papers copied an error, while only 68 criticized one. Half of copied errors are still being copied seven years later. Peer review removed about one error in five, and most corrections never reach the latest arXiv version.

A field outgrows its errors. It rarely corrects them.

More from this day

2026-11-18