Nikon strips first place from AI-generated video in Small World in Motion
Generative AI scandal has come to one of Nikon's competitions
Nikon disqualified the first-place winner of its Small World in Motion competition after determining the video violated rules against generative AI. The entry claimed to show abnormal beating of airway cilia in a child with primary ciliary dyskinesia, but experts said the cells looked nothing like those from PCD patients. The BBC reports the winner acknowledged using AI. Nikon has promoted the original second-place video, a microscopic view of a roundworm and a single-celled Dileptus, to first place, and says it will re-evaluate its rules.
What the statement doesn’t say is what role generative AI played in the video’s creation; whether it was fully synthetic, or if it was used to edit something that was once a real image.
- neom
Here is the video they disqualified: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aJSotKghcZ8
- altmanaltman
> The video in question supposedly showed “abnormal beating of airway cilia in a child with primary ciliary dyskinesia (PCD), a rare genetic disorder affecting respiratory function,” and the original press release announcing it as the winner had several paragraphs describing the importance of the imagery and how it was captured.
> the winner “acknowledged using AI,” and reports that other scientists raised the alarm about the video, with one expert in PCD saying that the cells in the video “look nothing like those from PCD patients.”
Imagine the gaslighting to the scientists with that press release. This is embarassing that they didn't do their due dilligence and just published it as if its real.
AI kind of won this one imo, or exposed what little fs the company gives about these competitions until it embarasses them. I wonder what their judging standards were pre AI
- sawjet
I don't understand how an AI can be scandalized. It's just a spicy auto complete. Sounds more like it's the photographers who are scandalized.