Why Gifted Kids Hear Rejection in a Neutral Comment

Rejection Sensitivity in Gifted and Twice-Exceptional Children

Why Gifted Kids Hear Rejection in a Neutral Comment

Rejection sensitivity runs on a spectrum, and for gifted and twice-exceptional children it is amplified by a nervous system wired to process signals quickly and deeply. Psychiatrist William Dodson coined Rejection Sensitive Dysphoria (RSD) to describe the extreme, almost physically painful reaction some people with ADHD have to perceived rejection. The piece covers overlapping frameworks—ADHD, autism, sensory processing sensitivity, and Dabrowski's overexcitabilities—and offers practical strategies like pre-correcting before feedback and separating performance from self.

Dodson found that the large majority of adolescents and adults with ADHD he surveyed recognized this experience in themselves, and a third named it the most impairing symptom they had.
  1. bonsai_spool

    One should be careful with vibe-written / vibe-aided articles here. Who knows what is actually supported vs what sounded okay and the author (who is not a clinician) then signed off on.

    Even the core idea, 'rejection sensitivity' is acknowledged not to be a diagnostic entity: so then how can we make definitive comparisons? Maybe clinical gestalt... but the author is not trained to see and evalaute patients.

  2. ChrisMarshallNY

    Ugh. I'm not sure that I'm comfortable giving the sensitivity its own diagnoses. I feel as if it's a secondary reaction to a chronic condition.

    I'm "on the spectrum," which, of course, means that my K-12 days were a living hell. It was bad. I spent most of my early years, acting as a punching bag for any bully or proto-bully that was feeling the need to let off some steam.

    Needless to say, I tended to be a bit "sensitive," during that period.

    I also learned, early on, that I was absolutely terrible at determining motivation in others. I have learned to ask, explicitly, before assigning motive, so the sensitivity has extended far past my bully-magnet days.

    These days, I'm fairly old, and have developed highly effective compensation/coping mechanisms, but it took a long time to get here.

    All that, to say that, in my case, I feel as if the "sensitivity" was real, but as a secondary symptom of my "normal" autism lite.

  3. hoppp

    "autistic individuals may have difficulty consciously processing social evaluative cues in the moment, meaning a child may not always recognize that what they are experiencing is a reaction to rejection, even while the physiological load of it is very real"

    Alexythemia is like a that, I can have anxiety without realizing it, all I see is that my hands are shaking, blood pressure rises but in the head I'm like whatever, I don't notice.

    However alexythemia also means no psychological reaction to physical emotion sensations.

    I would interpret this like some subconscious processing of social cues does occur in this case and it does trigger inner changes,but why it occurs does not make it into consciousness, so the alexythemia hides the reason for the body sensation but the sensation is strong enough to be noticeable and the lack of understanding for the strong reaction can cause people to flip out.

    I am not rejection sensitive at all btw, too dense to give a shit but its interesting.

  4. FinnLobsien

    This kind of AI-written article often does more harm than good. Rejection Sensitive Dysphoria is not a diagnosis (as the article admits).

    That means confidently stating who this applies to, what it feels like, and what to do about it is not a great idea because it could teach someone the wrong things.

  5. dahart

    > When adults consistently praise a child’s intelligence rather than their process or effort, mistakes stop feeling like normal setbacks and start feeling existential.

    Isn’t this a good reason to stop using the term “gifted”? Isn’t it now widely acknowledged that effort (among other things like creativity and self-conception) actually is part of intelligence?

    “Gifted” children are historically identified and classified via IQ tests (typically with the threshold IQ >= 130 - though the definition of what ‘gifted’ should mean is being debated), and using “gifted” for smart kids emerged and was popularized in the 1920’s when IQ tests were being developed by people who basically believed in eugenics, in the heritability of intelligence, and they wanted to identify the kids with the smart genes. [1] Using language like ‘profoundly gifted’ and ‘genius’ for high IQ has always been (mis)leading since IQ is a ranking, not an absolute measure of intelligence.

    I just searched and found an interesting recent paper arguing that ‘gifted’ is problematic and attached to science that is no longer valid, and should be improved or replaced. [2]

    [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intellectual_giftedness#Overvi...

    [2] https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/36278606/

More from this day

2026-10-04