French High Court Rules Rodin Museum's 3D Scans Are Not Public Documents

Treachery in the Rodin Museum 3D scan verdict

French High Court Rules Rodin Museum's 3D Scans Are Not Public Documents

After an eight-year freedom of information battle, France's Conseil d'État ruled that the Rodin Museum's 3D scans of public-domain sculptures are not administrative documents but part of its inalienable collection, making FOI law inapplicable. The decision reverses a lower court victory that had ordered the museum to release the scans and pay €1,500. The court also ordered the requester to pay €3,000 to the museum.

When France's highest court for administrative justice hears your eight-year freedom of information case, and the court's own legal analyst directly invokes surréalisme to argue that 'sometimes a document is not a document,' you know you're about to get wrecked.
  1. Animats

    The Rodin Museum's bronzes are not even "the originals", which makes this whole thing amusing.

    The originals created by Rodin were clay models, from which plaster molds were made. Those were used to cast bronzes. Not just one bronze copy, many copies. There are at least 23 copies of "The Thinker" cast during Rodin's lifetime, and even more later copies.[1]

    In the SF Bay Area, the Palace of the Legion of Honor has one. One of the point clouds shown is of Rodin's "Gates of Hell", and a copy of that can be seen outside the Cantor Arts Center at Stanford, which has a small garden of Rodin bronzes. So if you really need a 3D scan, there are lots of bronzes available to scan.

    What scares the Rodin Museum is that they are still selling reproductions.[2] Resin copies are available through the gift shop, and bronze copies can be ordered. They have a complicated argument about "moral rights" to justify their monopoly which is marginal at this late date. (Rodin died in 1917.)

    [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_The_Thinker_sculptures

    [2] https://boutique.musee-rodin.fr/en/10-sculpture-reproduction...

  2. SillyUsername

    Perhaps look at the case from another perspective.

    Ask if, since they used public money to create these, what public benefit was produced by it.

    If you can have them admit, or can prove, no public benefit, it's misspent public funds.

    If it's misspent public funds then its public reimbursement at the least for all the works they have scanned as a minimal response.

    You could argue the case the directors are liable for incompetence, or possibly criminality for knowingly misappropriating the public funds or contempt of court for earlier cases.

    When faced with this as a more serious charge, the museum may then choose to simply release the documents to settle the case. You may not even have to prove anything.

    IANAL but have been involved in (other country) public council appeals.

  3. simonw

    I really want to understand the perspective of the other side of this case. Why did this museum care so much about this issue? They appear to have put an enormous legal effort into preventing the release of these point cloud scans. Why?

  4. procaryote

    FOI is for administrative documents to increase transparency in government. Detailed 3D scans a museum does for research or preservation isn't an administrative document.

    If you want a 3d scan of these statues, there's a lot of them around in scannable places like parks etc. If you just want to win, you're wasting everyone's time for no good reason.

  5. MITSardine

    Fascinating work and write-up. This is like a vignette of France: weaponized mauvaise-foi, sacred institutions and, more generally, some remnants of an aristocratic hierarchy, and also probably a lot of honest technical incompetence.

  6. goobatrooba

    Very interesting discussion. Others here note a general question whether FOI laws are really intended to address such documents. But I have also another angle:

    Generally a public preservation grant will have conditions, especially if EU funded (not mentioned but well likely as EU finances huge digitalisation efforts).

    I'm surprised the author does not mention these grant documents which financed the digitalisation. I would expect these to have provisions on sharing/making available/publication. If they do you have a separate case: breach of contract (of either national or EU provisions). This would lead to financial penalties and generally wake the institutions up.

    https://www.europeana.eu/en

    https://digital-strategy.ec.europa.eu/en/library/basic-princ...

  7. contubernio

    Article is not useful because it does not bother to motivate why the scans were requested or why anyone other than a legalistic, formalistic person would consider them administrative documents. The author assumes all this is obvious and it isn't.

  8. pj_mukh

    Oh boy.

    I don’t want to freak the museum out but I have 360 degree footage of large sections of the museum (mostly for a spatial index) and now I’m wondering how high a quality I could get with splatting the sculptures and making it public.

    Would I get cease desisted for hosting from across the pond? Or would they be too lazy to come after me?

More from this day

2026-10-03