¿Por qué se trata a China como actor de amenaza pero no a India?
Why is China treated as threat-actor but not India?
He notado una discrepancia en cómo se perciben las contribuciones tecnológicas de diferentes países: cuando alguien dice que las acciones de India o los indios son un vector negativo para la tecnología, la gente se resiste, pero se puede decir lo mismo de China o los chinos y todos están de acuerdo. Me pregunto por qué existe este doble estándar. No acepto respuestas como 'doublethink', 'es 1984' o 'la gente es crédula'.
America thinks it is a martial power, a superpower. This is completely wrong. America has always been a mercantile power. [...] China, too, has always been a mercantile power. The problem is that China has in recent decades played the game better, with smarter industrial policy and less concentration of wealth and power in the financial and service industries. [...] India is neither a martial nor a mercantile power. To both China and the US, it's largely irrelevant; there's no foreseeable future where India can displace America's concentration of wealth or China's development trajectory.
China has been threatening to conquer Taiwan, for years. They have been building up their military, for years, with the explicitly stated goal of being able to conquer Taiwan. I haven't heard of India doing anything like that. China has had their secret police bullying and threatening Chinese people abroad, trying to get them to support China's positions. I haven't heard of India doing anything like that. China has been using critical materials - rare earths - as a political weapon. I haven't heard of India doing anything like that (though perhaps from lack of opportunity). [...] And then, China's government seems to have control over Chinese companies when they want it, in a way that India doesn't. For that reason, we don't trust critical tech from Chinese companies, because we fear that it may abruptly become unavailable to us in a crisis.
But India is expected to outdo US GDP by 2050. [...] Unlike BYD or Xiaomi, they're not a threat to the American image. Same goes for India.
There's tons of political nuance about this. China is poised to dominate the technology scenario in the not so far future, and there's not much the US can do but to keep the crosshair of public opinion on them. At the same time, American businesses are laying off en masse while seeking H1B and hiring overseas. It does not help that there are some pretty high profile south-Asian CEOs and CTOs, which ends up attracting even more scrutiny.
I think the default is to treat everyone else as a thread-actor and then rank them. Then in propagation you only talk about those you want to target based on the current political climate.
People in the West still think of each and every Indian person as if they were the reincarnation of Ghandi. That is: non-violent. Which is absolutely absurd but here we are.