A mathematician says Claude proved the Riemann Hypothesis, and the essayist calls it a surrender
Re: Riemann

Fernando Borretti reacts to an announcement in which a mathematician claims that, working with Claude, he proved the Riemann Hypothesis and formalized the argument without assumptions, crediting the model with outpacing him near the finish. Borretti sets the announcement's rapturous tone against Ayn Rand's account of Apollo 11 and Diego Rivera's mural Man, Controller of the Universe, and argues that placing Claude at the center of discovery is a betrayal of human ambition.
The Riemann announcement reads like a suicide note, or like the farewell message of a terminally-ill person who's about to undergo euthanasia.
- Kuyawa
I could not have solved GRH with Claude, openAI, DeepSeek or any other AI. Neither could 99.99% of you. AI is a tool, like a calculator that helped mathematicians long time ago calculate sine and cosine faster than we could, then computers, then the internet, now AI. Somebody has to use the tool and input the right parameters to get the right results. AI only searched for all the knowledge that exists and tried them all as directed, but that director is the one who deserves the credit, not me, not you, not the calculator, not claude
Until the day AI starts directing itself creating knowledge that doesn't exist yet with no one at the wheel. Anxiously waiting that day...
- doctorzook
If the measure of man is his ability so prove theorems, then the machines clearly outstripped most of us already.
But by that measure, most of us had already been beaten by other men.
I'll never be the next Euler or von Neumann or Einstein, and I'll confess to occasional pangs of regret that I'll never reach those peaks.
But mostly, I just enjoy learning about math and science, and delight in the small contributions I can offer.
And I'm the oddball: most people couldn't care less.
There must be more to man than math.
- jareklupinski
> Why should we explore, discover, invent, succeed, become more, struggle, win, become divine? We don’t want to be more. We don’t want anything.
why did i buy a skateboard? why did i break my arm riding it? why cant i wait to do it again?
same reason we're in tar pits :) there's something more you can almost taste when you're the only one there
- lf88
This post resonates a lot with me. It's depressing to see so many people rooting for a future in which human intelligence becomes irrelevant.
- fwlr
He’s right, it does read like a suicide note. It is precisely the tone of a terminal patient praising the skill, the care, the infinite patience of the doctor euthanizing him.
That’s affected me quite heavily. I think I should probably spend the day offline, actually.
- jhanschoo
> Why live? Our servants can do that for us. Why should we explore, discover, invent, succeed, become more, struggle, win, become divine? We don’t want to be more.
Historically and presently, most humans do not have the privilege resources to "explore, discover, invent, succeed, become more, struggle, win, become divine" in a way that was not already trodden by other people. We/they have to contend with "less".
- whimsicalism
I understand the sentiment, but I also can't imagine a world where we have poverty-eradicating technology but choose not to build it to preserve meaning. Such a world would be sort of morally grotesque, sacrificing the happiness of billions of people to preserve an abstraction.
- cs_throwaway
> It’s a betrayal and a surrender.
I did not not think this was the case reading https://alpo.ge/remark.pdf
It reads like is is delighted to deeply understand and explain what he helped uncover.
Some mathematicians are completely unwilling to understand formal proofs in Lean. This isn't new: formal logic was deemed boring by mathematicians decades ago. It has been kept alive in computer science (databases and programming languages esp).