Primordial black holes: only a tiny fraction might ever be visible
If tiny 'primordial' black holes exist

A phys.org piece explores how tiny primordial black holes — relics of the early universe — could surface in astronomical observations if they exist at all. Hacker News commenters zero in on the cautious wording: the "might show up" framing reads as solid science, while the word "few" implies only an incredibly small percentage of these black holes would ever be detectable.
The "might show up" part sounds like pretty solid science. Vs. the "few" sounds like it'd be an incredibly small percentage of them.
- klez
My knowledge of physics is rather limited (especially about anything besides Newtonian dynamics), but why would an atom-sized thing, even with the extreme density it has, be disruptive to a star when its mass is still that of an asteroid? I mean, wouldn't it be like a hit from an actual asteroid?
Can someone help me understand why it is different?
- A_D_E_P_T
So, to summarize: If an atom-sized, asteroid-mass primordial black hole is trapped by a sunlike star, it will sink to the core, form a swirling accretion disk, and launch magnetic jets that explode the star in a flash of high-energy light detectable by current telescopes.
I had to laugh when I realized that's basically the plot to Stephen Baxter's 1992 novel Timelike Infinity. In it, future cultists launch a primordial atom-sized black hole into Jupiter, which after some time would force it to explode in a particular high-energy way, with that explosion itself being a message to very distant observers.
- elvisgodevelop
An asteroid heats up and dissolves into plasma, whereas a captured primordial black hole can stay inside, keep accreting gas, and grow. Plus, "atom-sized" just refers to the event horizon—its gravity reaches much further out.
- OroPla
What does it mean for a black hole to be tiny? Aren't all of them roughly the same size: a tiny little point? Possibly smaller than an atom? I don't have understanding, but to my knowledge the difference between black holes is mass, not size. So if the same little point holds a lot of mass it will have a gravitational pull on things farther away.
Or do we include the gravitational pull when speaking of their size?
- search_facility
Interesting article, but this claim:
"Primordial blackholes ... they could represent a significant component of dark matter"
sounds strange. Afaik the problem of DM invisibility is that it is spread around, widely, not concentrated and hidden somewhere.