OpenSSL Maintainers Push Back on a CVSS 9.8 Buffer Overflow Fix
OpenSSL: Buffer overflow in EVP_EncodeBlock() (CVE-2026-121481, CVSS 9.8)

A pull request aims to patch CVE-2026-121481, a buffer overflow in EVP_EncodeBlock(), by returning -1 for NULL buffers, negative lengths, and oversized inputs. The author notes the flaw is reachable via a large -proxy_pass in openssl s_client. But reviewers object: returning -1 could break third-party callers that cast the result to size_t, and some argue the reproducer is synthetic and the issue belongs in documentation.
We already for STYLE.md say we should NOT add special case errors like this where we get a failure case that looks like a success.