John Carmack explains why 3dfx cards looked washed out

Why 3dfx 1 cards had such a washed out color output?

NeXT and 3dfx deliberately built near-linear color pipelines, a choice inherited from Pixar and SGI. With 10+ bits per channel that is correct, but their displays offered only 4 to 6 bits, and human vision is far more sensitive to relative changes in dark tones. Artists painted textures on conventional non-linear monitors, so 3dfx rendered them washed out. Carmack admits glQuake-era developers were too focused on raw speed to fix it.

If you only have a small number of discrete pixel values, you definitely don't want to spread them evenly from 0 to 1!
  1. AkBKukU

    I have two alternate observations, because VGA is an analog signal there are standards for what the voltages should be. But they were not always followed. Keep in mind that the first two Voodoo cards were also video switchers with a chip to output either the 2D passthrough or the internally generated 3D chip signal created by its own GENDAC.

    1. I have a Voodoo 2 paired with an S3 Virge/DX, the Voodoo 2 output level is lower. On a CRT I always have to make the image brighter when running a 3DFX game. Additionally, the V-Sync pulse is not the same as the Virge/DX and the Voodoo 2 image is shifted up.

    2. I have a Voodoo Rush which is the maligned hybrid model of 2D and 3D chipsets on a single card. It still uses the internal switching though. On this card the voltage issues are the opposite, the 2D output is significantly dimmer than the 3D which makes the 3D game clip badly when running something until the image is adjusted again.

    These problems are voltage level issues with the signal, not gamma. Adjusting gamma will not change the black or white voltage level of the signal. But a lower voltage signal may seem brighter as gamma is raised and the dynamic range is compressed.

    > we were so enthralled by the absolute performance of 3DFX that the color fidelity didn’t get as much attention as it should have.

    I would say it's more likely that they just didn't notice and the varying outputs from different 3DFX cards, with different GENDAC's, on differently calibrated CRTs just made i […]

  2. hmstx

    One other aspect of 3dfx looking a bit washed out beyond the gamma problem is the trickery performed in the RAMDAC before it blasted those cool pixels to the VGA port.

    If you remember, 3dfx screenshots were just as dithered as, say, an ATI Rage, but on screen it looked smoother (although a bit blurry) while the others looked visibly dithered still (see some 3dfx screenshots https://www.vogons.org/viewtopic.php?f=46&t=36548 )

    Part of it is the gamma shenanigans mentioned, and also the blur filtering pass taking place in the DAC which "upgrades" the image (eventually claimed to be so-called 22 bit precision for Voodoo3), introducing some quite visible smudging and hints of unexpected colors as a result.

    This has been approximated in shaders you can apply to most games with ReShade etc., take a look (https://www.vogons.org/viewtopic.php?t=36470)

  3. herodoturtle

    It's pretty cool that someone can ask an interesting graphics-related question, and John Carmack of all people steps in to answer it. And then even Eric S. Raymond adds a comment further below.

  4. Dwedit

    You might have heard about sRGB (the commonly used colorspace) not being linear, and that to get halfway between black and white (linear RGB of 50%), you get an sRGB value of around 74%.

    But there is one place where sRGB is truly linear, and that is signal voltage for a CRT display. 50% of sRGB truly means 50% of signal voltage (between the minimum and maximum voltages).

  5. tannhaeuser

    Hard to believe, but Nvidia, founded by former SGI engineers, was considered an entrepreneur and challenger of 3dfx, the dominant pioneer in PC 3D hardware 30 years ago.

    Edit: see comments re founders

  6. DavCreator

    https://xnotme.com/id_aa_carmack/status/2122478083319992513

  7. cmovq

    These days you just author your textures in sRGB, convert them to linear when they’re read, do all the filtering and lighting in linear space and convert the final render target to sRGB (or HDR). Of course this was much more difficult back then with fixed function hardware

  8. gwbas1c

    > If you only have a small number of discrete pixel values, you definitely don’t want to spread them evenly from 0 to 1! If you do, you will have good precision in the brights, but very stark “intensity bands” in the dark colors.

    That's probably why streaming video has so much banding in dark streams too.

More from this day

2026-11-17