A military analyst predicted how Ukraine would fight—and he was right

How Should Armies Fight?

A military analyst predicted how Ukraine would fight—and he was right

Jack Watling's 2023 book The Arms of the Future argued that sensors, weapon range, and precision have made traditional maneuver warfare impossible. In Ukraine, soldiers now live underground, avoid movement, and shelter in cities; a battalion commander says he needs buildings, not reinforcements. Watling's preferred fix: small mobile units that blind enemy sensors so troops can briefly mass and seize an objective.

A Ukrainian battalion commander tells Watling: 'I don't need reinforcements, I need buildings to fight from.'
  1. elevation

    You don't fight wars for the fun of fighting, you have tactical objectives.

    If your nation only survives the winter because of a supply of grain and heating oil, then any threat that cuts off those supplies will kill you eventually. Often economic solutions suffice, but if you must protect yourself by kinetic means, then the battlefield is determined by the location (and supply lines) of the threat.

  2. bluGill

    Plenty of analysts have examined the WWII tactics Germany used so well at the start and concluded they were very very risky and just some minor changes to French tactics would have defeated them (but at a different cost - France would have had to abandon allies to get the troops in the right place, even though the war would have looked different we would be picking on the France for that dishonorable action today)

    That is the problem with history. We can see what worked and didn't work. We can't nearly as easially know what is luck and what is good strategy/tactics. Many commenters talk about the current war as if everything changes, but it is never clear what is a major change and what is a blip that works now but soon be countered.

  3. rdtsc

    > The attacking Russians, who have no holes to sit in, no cities to shelter in, and can neither concentrate nor achieve surprise, are suffering astonishing losses

    But it still doesn’t bother them too much. Consider that they haven’t even started a full mobilization yet. They just keep sending groups of soldiers who then get droned, send another and so on. Eventually a few get through, so it’s a slowly advancing front.

  4. pjc50

    See the "survivability onion": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivability

    The Ukranian war is stuck in a slightly dystopian equilibrium because neither side can afford to gain WW2-scale air superiority, or even Iraq-war levels of air superiority. The increase in use of cruise missiles by Ukranians against strategic oil infrastructure may be the only way of changing that.

  5. spicyusername

    Pretty horrific to consider

More from this day

2026-11-16