Japan's Hometown Tax lets you redirect 40% of your local taxes to any town that bribes you with gifts
Japan's Hometown Tax (2018)
Japan's Furusato Nouzei system lets taxpayers divert up to 40% of their residence tax to any municipality they choose, receiving a full tax credit in return. Cities quickly discovered they could compete for donors by sending back gifts, from local plums to grave-cleaning services, and eventually near-cash gift cards. Participation exploded from 33,000 people in 2008 to 2.2 million in 2016, moving about $2.5 billion, as a bidding war drove rewards up to a government-capped 50%.
In 2008, about 33,000 people participated in the Furusato Nouzei system, principally out of genuine charitable concern. In 2016, it was about 2.2 million.
- lz400
I live in Japan. I use this every year. Patrick explained the why and how it works. I'll summarize it for the person who this system is available to. It's basically free money. In the end it's simple, you go to https://www.satofull.jp/ you buy stuff there, you get the money back in tax season time.
There's a limit of course, it's higher the more you make. The stuff in that page is typically overpriced by 3-5x but since its free, it's fine. In theory you buy meat and fruit and regional delicacies but lately there's lots of stuff including electronics and whatnot. There are some truly bizarre things too, especially if you sort by price and select the most expensive ones, my favorites are the 10m yen tier I'm going off my memory but I just can't forget these:
- A custom statue of yourself
- A sauna to install in your backyard
- A whole frozen cow
- A local celebrity from that town records whatever you want for a ringtone
- cloudbonsai
This is a way weirder system than the name suggests. patio11 explains it in detail in the article, but the gist is:
1. You can contribute to rural areas in return for a tax credit, effectively allowing you to redirect a portion of your taxes to another town.
2. The most important quirk of the system is that you can choose any towns to contribute to. There is no requirement of previous residence or whatever. In fact, most people contribute to towns with which they have no personal connection.
3. This ended up causing tax competition among local governments. Quite a few towns started advertising expensive "gifts" to contributers ("Give us your taxes and we'll send you some goodies"). It went so far that some towns got banned from the hometwon tax system.
It was introduced with good intension, but resulted in a very inefficient tax system.
- shioyama
I live in Japan. This is ridiculous take. It's not a good system: it creates perverse incentives to fight for everyone's tax money, rather than pay it where they live---i.e. where they consume the gov't services their tax money pays for. That means yes it can go from Tokyo to less populated regions, but it also means money that would have gone to regions starved for cash will now go to the region with the highest bidder, and the closer to cash, the more popular.
I live in a small city far from Tokyo, that desperately needs cash and that is bleeding youth to the bigger cities at a terrifying rate. But this is not the solution! Yes, paying taxes to where you live is not perfect. But furusato-nozei is so so much worse.
- andai
I often thought it might be better if people could actually literally vote with their dollars, choose how their tax dollars are allocated.
I thought (briefly) about the consequences of this idea: different governments would then need to become concerned with "advertising"... or in this case ... sending their citizens cans of plums :) That's very cute.
- guessmyname
Indeed. Good system, I send a portion of my taxes to my hometown in Shimane prefecture and get in return some of the goods from local farmers. I have always wished a similar system existed in America.