Why the CIA Prefers Trust Over Blackmail

A short history of the honey trap

Why the CIA Prefers Trust Over Blackmail

Sex and espionage have collided for centuries, from Mata Hari to the Stasi's male 'Romeos' who seduced West German secretaries. Yet culture shapes success: French affairs are so common that exposure carries little sting. A former CIA officer explains why US intelligence reportedly shuns honey traps — blackmail produces unreliable agents, while money, ideology or ego build lasting ones. He also recalls two bikini-clad women in a Balkan hotel asking him to fix their minibar.

Blackmail doesn't make for productive long-term agents, many former case officers say.
  1. mrandish

    Since the story broke over a week ago, it's been clear to anyone passingly familiar with intelligence tradecraft that Alice was not a "spy". Today, having exhausted the salacious surface story, MSM editors are finally printing the reality their writers knew all along. From the NYT:

    > "People briefed on the intelligence say it appears that she was not a trained intelligence officer but rather an “asset,” someone providing information secretly to the Ministry of State Security. Chinese espionage is complicated. There are a range of ways that Chinese business executives can conduct espionage for the Beijing government, from simply reporting what they know to taking active direction." (https://www.nytimes.com/2026/11/13/us/politics/nvidia-alice-...)

    And a WSJ editorial this morning started by conceding that Ms. Huang being an alleged MSS asset has always been the least important and interesting part of the story. The allegations about Alice have been widely known in the White House for over a year. Strong suspicions about "Jensen's China Problem" were surfaced publicly over six months in a report by Culpepper, but the media wasn't interested in until they had an insider official willing to leak it 'unofficially'. And that happened last week, motivated by a long-simmering factional dispute in the White House. Between:

    China AI Hawks: State (Rubio), Defense (Hegseth), Treasury (Bessent) Depts

    vs

    China AI Trade Pragmatists: Commerce Dept (Lutnick), White House advisors and trading […]

  2. pelagicAustral

    Who phased out "honeypot"? Is that not 'hip' anymore? I honestly missed that memo.

More from this day

2026-11-14