Italy fines Meta €805M for quietly mining 20 million users' photo galleries
Italy fines Meta €805M over photo privacy
Italy's data protection authority hit Meta with an €805 million fine for letting Facebook's Android app pull photos, videos and metadata from users' galleries without specific consent. The gallery-suggestion feature, live since 2023, relied on a single generic permission prompt that never made clear it covered photo access. Regulators cited roughly 20 million affected Italian Android users, an ongoing infringement, and Meta's lack of cooperation. Meta can still appeal.
Meta accessed photographs, videos and related metadata belonging to Italian users without obtaining specific consent and without properly informing them.
- wafflemaker
I only give Facebook Messenger access to photos that I need to share. Not more, because I don't trust them not to abuse our relationship and misuse anything they can put their hands on, including photos and documents I don't mean to share.
Am I wrong and paranoid? Maybe, but it's not my fault that that's my perception of big tech. It's their own actions.
And that an average Joe doesn't realize how much access to his private life he gives them? Looks like somebody decided that these predatory tactics are not cool and even people not in the know should be protected.
- dahdum
> According to Italy’s regulator, Facebook requested access to the gallery via a single authorisation valid for the entire app, preceded by a generic notice requesting enabling of other features, which did not allow users to understand that they were also authorising suggestions from their gallery.
This sounds so benign to me.
- simonw
I wish articles like this would be more technically vigorous.
What actually happened here? Was the Facebook app uploading every photo on your phone in order to run a bit of ML to help recommend images that might be a good fit for specific posts? Were they doing ML stuff on the device directly? Were they doing anything else with the photos aside from powering this "suggested image" feature?
I get that Rapporteur.com might not be the best venue to answer these questions, but I'd be shocked if any coverage of this story got into the details of how this stuff actually worked.
- mentalgear
This can only be the beginning, otherwise it's just the cost of doing business for a company with the business model of polarizing the world and profiting off of it in the 100s of billions or even trillions.
- Poudlardo
Do they ever pay those fines?