The NFL Is Roofing Over Its Best Feature

Too Many Stadiums with Roofs

The NFL Is Roofing Over Its Best Feature

Seven new NFL stadiums are in the works, and nearly all of them will have roofs—translucent ETFE membranes that let in light while keeping out weather. By 2031, only 10 of 30 stadiums will be fully open-air. The trend makes financial sense: owners can host concerts and events year-round. But it strips football of the rain, snow, and wind that make games unpredictable, memorable, and distinct.

Markets produce goods, but not good taste. Corporate actors crave centralized solutions, predictability, and efficiency, and all of that will generally come at the expense of risk, character, and flavor.
  1. Jeremy1026

    For football it all comes down to one day in early February. They want to host a Super Bowl. Aside from MetLife, nothing open air in a cold climate has hosted the Super Bowl in the last 20 years. I'm not sure what deal the Giants/Jets had to do to host in 2014, probably only happened because it was new that year, and I doubt they host another at MetLife ever.

  2. RankingMember

    Teams with indoor stadiums have been found to do worse in away games played outside, which isn't super surprising to me, but is an interesting aspect to note:

    https://ww2.amstat.org/meetings/proceedings/2014/data/assets...

    I think the prevalence of roofed stadiums boils down to the NFL usually choosing roofed stadiums to host Super Bowls in the modern era. Cities want to host Super Bowls, and so if they're going to invest in a new stadium, they're usually going to choose the stadium type that gets them in the mix for a Super Bowl.

  3. mchusma

    Why wouldn’t you build a roof? It means conditions inside are great at all times.

    I will say sofi is not great because they don’t go far enough m. The translucent roof and no ac (it’s got open sides in some spots) as far as I can tell make it really uncomfortable at times, almost worse than roof or no roof. So in my opinion if you are building a billion dolllar facility, put a roof on it.

  4. thehappypm

    Does the author not realize that other things happen in stadiums besides football? It’s much better to be able to have concerts and other events reliably and with comfortable customers, people don’t want to bundle up in 35° DC winter weather to go see a concert

  5. olsondv

    Lambeau Field will never have a roof. The shareholders are too proud of its Frozen Tundra reputation.

More from this day

2026-11-17