Open Source Was Never Neutral—and That's the Point

The Myth of Neutral Code

Open Source Was Never Neutral—and That's the Point

The nostalgia for a "neutral" open source is a myth. Stallman's Free Software movement was explicitly moral and anti-authoritarian; the 1998 rebrand to "Open Source" was a deliberate corporate sanitization that stripped out the ethics. The author argues today's backlash against codes of conduct and AI-slop bans reveals a double standard: corporate and state control is treated as neutral baseline, while community self-governance is branded "political."

A platform that enforces zero community standards isn't neutral. It simply chooses to prioritize the comfort of bad actors over the safety of everyone else.
  1. delichon

    This is the logic of "if you're not with us you're against us." It denies the possibility of neutrality even by inaction. The concept of neutrality becomes the myth, and there's no point in debating whether it applies to any domain, because that becomes false as a tautology. From this perspective the killing of noncombatant civilians of an enemy country is a moral good to be celebrated, since "noncombatant" is a myth too.

  2. hatradiowigwam

    This sounds like a /lot/ of opinions on a /lot/ of open source work - that the author has contributed nothing to. Snipe at RMS, trivialize GNU, and add all types of emotional nonsense that didn't exist at the time all this free software was being written. The author would should that - except they were likely not born yet, and are speaking on concepts they are utterly ignorant of.

  3. deepnet

    Modern AI is not neutral but opinionated.

    The author well points out the history of Free, open source and MIT licensed Softwares derives much from its founders.

    Yet people contributed under its various licenses, seeing that the license protected their differing levels of freedoms.

    By contributing they entered into a contract with the licenses.

    FOSS software mirrors society in being polarised and divided along various lines.

    Many licenses now have codes of conduct for the community attached AFAIK to protect contributors against this polarisation.

    The movement like most requires dynamic adaptation to face new challenges and those that choose to disagree with a groups license and surrounding documents are free to fork it.

    Users are free to complain, gripe and campaign for their own point of view. Just because the fork you agree with cannot attract developers, mindshare or users should not be used to indite other forks.

    Yet here we are today in the AI era and the most prevalent license today is the corporate doctrine of maximising shareholder value to which all other causes are secondary.

    The ability to have alternative software, OSes and AIs is important for the freedom to have alternative views of any sort.

    Society is extremely polarised politically and FOSS reflects these perhaps insurmountable divisions.

    Divide and conquer would seem to be in effect. Democracy is the ability to seek reasonable compromise with those whom we disagree. This is not always possible sometimes moral […]

More from this day

2026-11-14