Italy fines Meta $887M for quietly pulling Android users' photos
Italy fines Meta $887M over Android users' data access
Italy's data protection regulator hit Meta with an $887 million penalty over how its app accessed Android users' photo galleries, ruling that the consent flow never clearly explained what people were agreeing to. Hacker News commenters were less focused on the fine than on the tally: one user added up Meta's prior EU penalties to roughly €5.2 billion, bringing the total past €6 billion — and still called it a slap on the wrist.
Wait, they could see what we were doing inside our bedrooms, and they got away with a fine?
- chistev
It seems like every time Meta (Facebook) hits the front page of Hacker News it's for something negative.
- nsoam
How did they access users photos without consent? Did they run some exploit on Android to access the photo without showing the user the consent prompt? The article is really lacking in details.
- k0morebi
Is there a running total of how much the EU and member states rake in through tech company fines per year? It has to be pretty high by now.
Edit: I see another commenter linked https://enforcementtracker.com/. Very useful resource
- loeg
> Finding the company had accessed Android users' photographs and videos without obtaining their consent or informing them.
> Users must grant permission on their device before the feature can operate, and they can change that permission at any time in their settings.
> The fine is equivalent to about 0.47% of the group's global revenue.
What is Italy protecting Italians from here? I think it's clear consent was given at some point. So the objection is what? They need to ask consent again periodically? Or on a feature-by-feature basis? Who was conceivably harmed, and how?
How does Meta accept user content in the future without running afoul of the exact same rule again?
- poody
I have never seen any proof that they actually pay these.. Can someone enlighten me? (I would just ignore 'em... maybe I would get a strongly worded letter..)
- amelius
Wait, they could see what we were doing inside our bedrooms, and they got away with a fine?
- LaFolle
If Meta indeed is at fault then why Meta's iOS app is also not charged with same exploit as its android app? Does how consent work in iOS different from that in Android?
- simonebrunozzi
Besides the fine itself (probably good news? Probably too little to matter? Unsure), the topic of Meta/Facebook being a menace to our lives is an ever important one to me, in relation to my family.
It is well known, and discussed, that young kids are particularly weak in relation to social media. Meta probably represents the strongest, "evilest" company in that regard.
What will we do, as a society, to make our lives better? Possibly without pitch forks.
- akshatjiwan
I don't think these fines are even making the slightest difference. Meta probably writes them off as the cost of doing business. As do other big tech companies.
- lokar
They should be required to put a warning at the top of all future permission prompts explaining that meta has a history of lying about data use and violating privacy law.