Bill Gates Says Claude Codes as Well as He Does — and That Says Everything

The Claude Delusion

Bill Gates Says Claude Codes as Well as He Does — and That Says Everything

Tech success breeds a dangerous illusion: that being great at code means being great at everything. The author skewers Bill Gates for inventing novel biology questions to test AI and for calling Claude "as good as I am" — which, by his own logic, makes it "superhuman." The same overconfidence, the piece argues, fuels both AI doomsday panic and billionaire utopianism, and conveniently absolves people of responsibility when their "agents" misbehave.

That the capability of doing long-running, complex tasks has now gotten to the point that they are superhuman at writing code and in finding flaws in code.
  1. ianm218

    I find the authors point not very compelling.. Bill Gates was by all accounts an exceptional programmer at one point and then spent a long time evaluating software engineers. He seems like a natural person to gauge AI progress in coding?

    Around when AI was getting much better at SQL I was writing SQL everyday at work and had been for years. I don’t think it would’ve been hubris for me to judge that it was getting really good and would shortly be super human at SQL. It would’ve been correct anyway.

  2. cronin101

    I think this is written forgetting a lot of the context of the time (I was at a relevant part of the industry to be present around some of the early “oh shit this thing works” moments).

    It was absolutely not a given that next-token prediction would scale to the point that it could answer outside of its training domain (this is the point about “made up questions”, it was important to test it on material outside of the training set since the scale of training was yet-unheard-of at the time).

    Further, the success of post-training on verifiable tasks (coding) was also a complete shock that changed the world overnight. LLMs jumped the “I can make code” to “I confidently can make code that solves your problem” chasm suddenly, and it has changed the industry.

    For someone so invested in this from the early days (remember the scale of Microsoft’s commitment) it is entirely logical that testing things “on day one” would occur and this would be a much bigger shock compared to most people that learned of advances at the same time as the rest of the world. (There are huge delays between research capabilities and shipping)

  3. jmathai

    This article first makes a point that Gates isn’t expert enough in biology to assess AIs capability to answer complex questions on the topic as being a breakthrough.

    Then immediately goes on to say that his comments about AI coding are arrogant despite being an expert in that field with more experience than nearly anyone.

    Unsure how to interpret that.

  4. blincoln

    People on the author's side of this debate just haven't seen the firsthand evidence yet. I can understand being skeptical until then, but they owe it to themselves to give late-2026 frontier models a try.

    The lightbulb moment for me was when I gave Claude Code a tough reverse-engineering problem: understanding how a complex, proprietary encoding scheme worked, then building an encoder and decoder. There are some additional complicating factors that I can't disclose, because this was for work, but it was a tough problem.

    For context, I've been doing RE for over 25 years. I'm not the best in the world, but I'm pretty good at it when I can find the time.

    A coworker and I had spent about a week on the work, and I estimated it would take us another 2-3 to complete the work. We had figured out how about 3/4 of the messages were encoded, but the rest just didn't make sense.

    I gave Claude Code our notes, and in 15 minutes it had finished figuring out the rest of the protocol and built a command-line decoder. I asked it to add an encoding feature, and in another ten minutes, it had done that as well. It tested all of its own code extensively using our corpus of real data.

    The decoder worked perfectly on all of our existing captures as well as new data collected after that.

    I had to make a small change to the encoder that was related to one of the things I can't disclose. I don't hold that against the model, because it didn't have access to the real product to test its output against. […]

  5. siva7

    > I picked on Bill Gates above to illustrate the overconfidence effect

    After having read your blog i can assert you've demonstrated that effect on yourself. Bill has all capability and credentials proven so we know this guy is an authority on software engineering topics, you have zero if i'm not mistaken.

  6. jrm4

    Author is spot on on Bill Gates. By his own admission, his company essentially missed the coming of the Internet, and we all literally suffer today for it.

    He missed the coming interconnectedness of the machines and instead presumed that every computer was going to be a fancy copy machine calculator (that will never talk to others, thus security is not needed).

    A massive hole in perception.

  7. hliyan

    The first part of the article makes sense in that:

    In any system of competing agents (such as human beings) where the reward for performance can enhance performance, will always result in even minor random differentials in initial performance exponentially accumulating until one or a handful of individuals dominate. In such a system, only a small portion of success can be attributed to innate skills. So it's true that success in itself, while signaling fitness to survive, does not necessarily signal an outsized ability to make accurate judgements.

    I'm not entirely clear what the second part of the article is trying to convey. Is it that highly successful individuals attribute their success entirely to their skill and therefore when a machine is able to replicate their skillset, they are surprised and consider the technology to be world-altering?

  8. dgreensp

    It’s a fun read.

    But today’s agents are “superintelligent,” the same way that trains are “superlocomotive”—that is, faster than a running human. And they can carry more. Trains are just better at getting from point A to point B than humans.

    That doesn’t mean trains are a superrace and humans are obsolete, just that we’ve built machines that can do something more effectively than our bodies are physically capable of, as usual.

    Intelligence isn’t what makes us human. A human who can’t play chess or write a sonnet is still a human being.

    They are called “agents” because they can, and do, perform actions autonomously on our behalf. Virtual agents are not a new thing.

More from this day

2026-11-14