After 15 Years, a ServerFault Moderator Steps Down as Site Traffic Collapses

Calling It Quits on ServerFault

After 15 Years, a ServerFault Moderator Steps Down as Site Traffic Collapses

A moderator elected in ServerFault's first community election in 2011 is quitting after over 15 years. The site now gets just 2-3 questions a day, down from its 2011-2012 peak. He describes how cross-cultural escalation norms once sparked flame wars, and how recent StackExchange-wide spam campaigns forced him to spend evenings manually banning spammers in real time.

A particularly volatile mix were the Russian speakers and the folk from the United Kingdom (this was before Brexit), where the very British snide (a plus-one or two escalation from just asking questions, the next step was ad hominem attacks) was taken as an invitation to fight by the Russian speakers (whose plus-one escalation typically was ad hominem attacks, which means the brits saw this as escalation and moved on to flame war), both of which deeply and horribly offended US-based users for whom both were plus-two or plus-three escalations, definitely not a plus one.
  1. CodeCompost

    People may be dismissive of Serverfault and the other sites but pretty much all LLMs are trained on them.

  2. ewwhite

    17 years and 202,000 internet points -https://stackexchange.com/leagues/2/alltime/serverfault

    I contributed heavily to that site and spent the meat of my IT career posting about my gained experience. It helped me get jobs, and opened all sorts of consulting opportunities. I used to proudly point at that body of work because Stack Exchange and ServerFault were universally known in the industry.

    It is wild knowing the LLMs were trained on these contributions. And today, I encounter IT professionals who confidently say, "I've never used anything from that site"

  3. kazinator

    The stackexchange sites are too fragmented into too many narrow topics for the traffic. They should consider merging.

    E.g. Network Engineering and Server Fault could easily be one thing. Just ignore the questions you're not into about problems with switches, if application services are more your thing. Throw in Super User also: "TechExchange".

  4. adamors

    How is this page so bad to read on mobile?

  5. Lerc

    I guess that's a problem with content provided by karma farmers. When they decide to farm something else (gith7b stars now?) the flow stops. I think there also might be a tendancy for the culture to chase away people providing information purely so that others have access to it.

    While the use of Chatbots has diminished the utility of using the service as a direct interface, the information that Chatbots provide sourced some of that from here. There is possibly now a need for a new type repository of queries and answers in a different form. Perhaps people can have a skill on their Chatbots that gets them to post solutions into a wiki for issues that people have actually had that were solved by lengthy investigation.

More from this day

2026-10-07