Judge Calls Flock's Warrantless Searches 'Indiscriminate Mass Surveillance'
Federal judge calls Flock 'indiscriminate mass surveillance'

A federal judge ruled that a Tulsa deputy violated a woman's Fourth Amendment rights by searching Flock Safety's license plate database without a warrant, based solely on her California plate. The judge suppressed evidence found after the search, including 91 pounds of meth, and warned that Flock's passive cataloging of public movements amounts to indiscriminate mass surveillance. The ruling adds to growing backlash against Flock, with Florida and Texas halting use and Senator Sanders introducing a bill to ban federal agencies from using such systems.
This is a type of indiscriminate mass surveillance. It is not targeted on a single individual... It is a tool that collects information about all vehicles that pass by any network-connected camera at all times, and it serves up the information to law enforcement on demand.
- JKCalhoun
License plate reader?
So the device should require very specific license plates to scan for—not the current dragnet. The software should only "ping" when there is a confident match with said license plate(s)—and merely log which license plate, time stamp a single photo, and note the confidence level of it being a match.
The frame buffer should be the only place (a frame of) video is ever stored at all (excepting the high-confidence match indicated above).
The only issue remaining would be whether we trust the device/software to have complied (and not have a backdoor) and of course there needs to be a legal warrant for every license plate uploaded (and it should expire fairly frequently, likely requiring a new warrant to continue canning for the plate).
- joshheitzman
Yes, that's what they are. But does that mean are they breaking federal law or unconstitutional? I believe we've been told by the courts repeatedly that we should have no expectation of privacy out in public.
- ghm2180
To Google and apple's credit they have at the least made location history stored on device instead of dealing with the slippery slope of warrants that ask for all devices around a point. Google specifically decided after a court ruling to get out of the morass of server side storage. There is a lot wrong with how permissioning works on android and Google services but this is not one of them.
- hypfer
> The deputy then used the woman’s travel history in Flock as part of the justification for searching her car, where he allegedly discovered 91 pounds of meth.
That sentence does make this less of a win tbh, given that with it, it's just an actual example of the technology doing the job it is supposed to do.
Like this, it's almost a trojan horse of something pretending to be PR for A, but actually being effective PR for B.
- kingcauchy
I'm pretty sure we're living in the prequel to Minority Report right now.
- vjvjvjvjghv
Is there realistically a chance that we won't get total surveillance in the next decades? Unless something dramatically changes, I just don't see how it won't end any other way.
- wonderwonder
The issue with flock is pair it with a competent Ai system and you have full realtime surveilance of every civilian everywhere there are flock cameras. Press a button and you have "Bob Smith's" or very likely "Ex GF of legal figure" complete travel history on demand as well as current location. It's too much power to give a government let alone flawed individual humans
- cryptozeus
"he allegedly discovered 91 pounds of meth"....not helping the case but overall I agree against mass surveillance like this