C2PA's exclusion feature lets you sign nothing and fake timestamps

How to hack time, with C2PA

C2PA's exclusion feature lets you sign nothing and fake timestamps

David Buchanan demonstrates a time-hacking exploit in C2PA by abusing arbitrary byte-range exclusions. By excluding the entire file, he creates a valid signature over an empty hash, allowing post-hoc tampering without invalidating the signature or the trusted timestamp. He shows a photoshopped EuroMillions ticket with a valid C2PA timestamp hours before the draw. The flaw is known but unfixed; he suggests format-specific exclusion rules.

We're effectively signing nothing at all, but as of today all the C2PA verification tools I can find don't flag anything as unusual.
  1. bawolff

    > C2PA allows for arbitrary "exclusions". These are byte ranges within the file which are excluded from signature calculations

    Glad to see we learned from the mistakes of SAML.

  2. mugul

    Would have been great to have that sorted out and fixed before passing the EU AI Act and forcing all content generation providers to embed C2PA manifests in their outputs...

  3. kaszanka

    Only tangentially related, but knowing that remote attestation and co. will only ever get... "better" fills me with impotent rage like almost nothing else. https://www.lafkon.net/tc/ (2004) was so very prescient.

More from this day

2026-10-03