Greg Kroah-Hartman debunks AI security hype: 79 vulnerabilities, only 10 real

Greg Kroah-Hartman – Security in the LLM Age [video]

In a Kernel Recipes 2026 talk, Greg Kroah-Hartman dissected 79 vulnerabilities reported by an AI model. Most were noise: 24 lacked detail, 14 weren't bugs, 3 were fabricated, and 15 were already fixed. Only 10 were genuine fixes. He warns against uncritical parroting of AI security press releases.

GHK called this "10 'real' bugfixes", which to me sounds like there's a wild hype machine around these companies and uncritical parroting of every press release they make that falls apart when you engage the affected real experts.
  1. usernomdeguerre

    Greatly appreciated the candor. I've included a few slides into text that i thought were eye-opening to me:

    From his Kernel Recipes 2026 slide on Mythos

    ```

    Mythos's 79 vulnerabilities:

    24 - no detail at all "something crashed"

    14 - not a bug at all

    3 - totally made up data

    15 - already fixed in latest release

    - 11 by others

    - 4 by anthropic

    20 - fixes were needed

    - 7 "assume a malicious filesystem image"

    - 2 "assume you can inject a malicious network packet into the middle of the stack"

    - 2 "NOMMU"

    - 6 sctp networking issues for untrusted devices

    - 2 ipv6 minor network issues

    - 1 gpu driver for local malicious user

    ```

    GHK called this "10 'real' bugfixes", which to me sounds like there's a wild hype machine around these companies and uncritical parroting of every press release they make that falls apart when you engage the affected real experts.

  2. djoldman

    > So what all of mythos; that whole big marketing issue of 79 bugs came down to one hour of kernel development.

    If you're someone at OpenAI or Anthropic and you truly believe what you're making could destroy the world, this is the kind of thing that isn't doing you any favors when it comes to convincing the public. The dissonance here is stark:

    - widely proclaiming that your new model is so dangerous it needs to be released only to select people, for safety

    - widely proclaiming the model easily found 79 bugs in linux, except that GKH says it took 1 hour to fix all of them because most weren't bugs and the rest were almost all completely trivial, unimportant, and/or not severe

    It doesn't mean the model isn't dangerous or super capable but wow this makes it realllll easy to doubt it and any future announcement.

  3. devy

    At 3m19s Greg KH revealed what Mythos did in "revealing" 79 CVEs - pure pattern matching the previous decades of kernel developer's patches, and applying those mechanisms elsewhere to see if they have been universally patched. And Anthropic didn't cite Kernel Developers who original fixed/patched the CVEs like a decent human being would do. So yeah, Anthropic has the same problem OpenAI had for citing original work.

  4. blinkingled

    It's great to hear about $topic from someone no-nonsense and in-the-know like Greg KH. You can verify all of this too - since, well Linux kernel. (As opposed to what Microsoft or Apple claims to fix as far as LLM finds.)

    Mythos may not be great today but it is not far fetched to imagine bug discovery, analysis and fixes can be made much quicker, accurate and even newly possible with specialized models trained on say Linux kernel specifics - with codemap/coding standards/threat models, good and bad coding patterns, tools to validate etc. an LLM can be much more relentless than humans and if it has the help to be accurate it will be worth the electricity burned. Oh and another model trained on triage data to validate the first one's findings would be good.

    (I think Microsoft is doing this internally - different models trained internally alongside Mythos - there was some talk about it on the tubes, don't recall where exactly.)

  5. tombh

    At 15m18s he quotes LG Research "Common corpus contains only 20% legally allowed-to-be-used data". But he doesn't comment on how Linux itself legally navigates accepting patches from evidently illegally sourced means. He just says, "We'll let the courts deal with that". So what happens if courts do decide that it is illegal to use LLM output that's strikingly similar to copyrighted training data? Does anybody know of any discussions that have happened about this from within the Linux project?

    I'm fully aware of the philosophical arguments about transformative use etc. But I'm more interested in the concrete reality of high profile projects navigating this novel legal territory.

  6. Aissen

    Nice to see Kernel Recipes covered again on HN. Shameless plug: I do the live blog: it's incomplete, imperfect and has typos; but it's written and published during the presentations. On this talk : https://kernel-recipes.org/en/2026/2026/09/22/live-blog-day-...

  7. asaiacai

    cool to see a really grounded analysis of the "security" and LLMs. I use agents in on the day-to-day for generating implementation but this just furthers my belief that humans and especially human reviewers remain critical for the sustainability of software systems.

    also, lol at "The bots are dumb - they want to please you line". LLMs have pretty much ruined technical collaboration between contributors. I get tilted every time an discussion has "but my claude said this..."

  8. shieldagent

    The asymmetry is the killer: reports are nearly free to generate now, but the verification cost stayed exactly the same.

More from this day

2026-10-02