Court Blocks Utah's VPN Law, Calling It a Technical Impossibility

Court agrees with EFF: Utah's VPN law demands a technical impossibility

Court Blocks Utah's VPN Law, Calling It a Technical Impossibility

A federal judge issued a preliminary injunction against Utah's SB 73, which would have forced adult websites to block VPN users or verify every visitor's location. The court agreed with EFF that perfect geolocation is impossible, making the law unconstitutional. The ruling sets a precedent against anti-VPN mandates that demand invasive surveillance and threaten privacy nationwide.

Because the law requires perfection in the absence of perfect geolocation tools, Aylo would need to verify those 28 million users—whether located in Salt Lake City, Boston, New Orleans, Anchorage, or Honolulu—to ensure compliance and avoid liability.
  1. SoftTalker

    > platforms are left with an impossible choice: completely block all VPN traffic nationwide or withdraw access from Utah entirely

    Is it even possible to reliably know that a connection is from a VPN? Anyone can proxy through a random hosting provider.

  2. 1vuio0pswjnm7

    "As we've said time and time again: the internet will always route around censorship."

    It won't route around self-censorship that arises out of surveillance

    Nor will it take a stand against SNI which is a dead simple means of implementing censorship that's in widespread use every day for years

  3. usernomdeguerre

    >As we’ve said time and time again: the internet will always route around censorship.

    Is this still true, or has it become a truism? It seems nations like Iran and China (and events like Kashmir come to mind) have progressed the state-of-the-art and playbook to where we can't actually say it definitively will route around it.

    Now seeing that the US and EU are flirting with these similar restrictions it's making me wonder how we'll be able to keep hold of these principles.

    Maybe my concern with that adage is ultimately its passive voice, since it takes 'active' action by people to give us those options, and will probably take more actions by more people to keep it alive now.

  4. kramer2718

    Fascism is on the march. Dirty pictures aren't the real reason governments want this level of control over the internet. You can be sure that we'll see worse. Glad we won this battle.

  5. twiclo

    I'm not looking to get into a debate on the law just curious why these websites can't force accounts for everyone just like the gambling sites do.

  6. HiPhish

    > Utah's VPN law demands a technical impossibility

    How does legislation work in the US? How can an impossible law pass? Is it just some boomer stomping his feet like a toddler "I know what I want, and I want it now" without consulting any technical experts, and then private organizations like the EFF and courts have to clean up the mess?

  7. rhcom2

    > It even went so far as to prohibit websites from offering instructions on how to use a VPN to bypass these checks

    How is that not a blatant first amendment violation?

  8. forshaper

    Can someone explain why it wouldn't work to have porn companies use only certain domains, and filter based on those domains, if people are so intent on blocking it?

  9. nikanj

    Since when do lawmakers cared about technical impossibilities?

  10. nadermx

    Remember to renew your support for the EFF. They take on some interesting cases

More from this day

2026-10-02