AI is Solving Math's Hardest Problems, and Mathematicians Are Grieving

To grieve, or not to grieve?

Language models are now cracking problems humans couldn't, and the math community is reeling. From denial to depression, many mathematicians are grieving what they see as a loss. But not everyone: some, like Kevin Buzzard, are excited. He argues that the real value of math is human understanding, yet AI's rapid progress threatens even that refuge. A provocative look at AI's impact on mathematics.

You cannot fool Lean; one learns this very early on. Lean will not accept proof by authority or proof by intimidation; it doesn’t work like that. I feel safe with Lean.
  1. youoy

    In contrast to what these philosophical pieces tend to convey, the main crisis in mathematics is a labour one.

    Mathematitians exchanged proofs for employment. That was the currency. Now they cannot use that currency anymore, so the question is how does someone know if they should hire an unknow person or not?

    Philosophicaly who cares if you like more theory building or theorem proving? You dont need to convince anyone. The only solution is to be curious and follow your interests and naturally humanity will redefine what the new mathematics feels like.

    You cannot convince anyone about it, its not something rational.

  2. js8

    I am also an optimist about AI, although I worry about the labor aspect as well (as a leftist I see the class aspect of this, on the other hand, as a computer programmer, computers were also originally meant to replace human labor, and we all see what happened).

    My view is, current top AIs do multiple different things:

    1. Interpret and output natural language

    2. Do formal logical reasoning

    3. Do informal logical reasoning

    4. Provide encyclopedic knowledge

    5. Discern vague instructions/statements and fill the most likely gaps (kind of error correction)

    6. Serve as a model of the human mind, a proxy for a person

    7. Translate between different languages, formal and informal

    All these things are combined in these huge, hard-to-understand blobs of weights. I think humanity would be better off by understanding each aspect separately, but disentangling them will take decades of philosophical research. So there is a lot of interesting work ahead of us.

  3. sachaa

    I share the optimism here. Connecting dots across knowledge, lived experience and purpose remains, to me, a deeply human pursuit. The more AI discovers, the more possibilities we have to connect those discoveries to questions that matter to us.

  4. dsubburam

    > But do I “understand” the proof of Fermat’s Last Theorem, given that earlier this year I gave 22 hours worth of lectures on the topic?

    Even if no one human can understand the entirety of a complex proof, surely we can piece together multiple experts' separate understandings, so the community as a whole 'understands' the proof?

    Is there value in us 'understanding' a proof? Even if no single human can understand a complex proof soup-to-nuts, and we have to piece together several experts' understandings?

    If the answer is Not really, then the value of a proof is its utility, its utility in making new products/services, and its utility in making new proofs. If in the case of abstract math, all the utility is of the latter kind (making new proofs), then we have a pyramid scheme here.

  5. Eridanus2

    https://thebhc.org/node/97369

    "The Decline and Fall of the Horse"

    I argue that the Industrial revolution created 'unemployment' in beasts of yoke and burden at a larger scale than humans. So, there may be something instructive in that turn of events, even if it's not a highly representative analogue of the current ones. Of course, it's like saying what's a house cat to do when there's no more mice to hunt (assuming it remains fed). Maybe knowledge workers will become qualified pets if they prove cute enough.

    My border collie will be pretty depressed though, once it's out of a job (maybe replaced by a drone sheep-herd).

  6. Kuyawa

    "if we get on board now then they will take us to extraordinary new places. And after we have arrived, the new adventure will begin"

    This is the thought of an AI optimist and the one I share, new adventures, more tools, better results, and a never ending pool of ideas to work on

  7. GPerson

    Kevin, once the world has the ultra massive Lean database which comprises completions of all mathematical theories, and combinations of these, and all the known modes of generalization of these, why will the world fund mathematicians? Genuine question. I’d like to hear your view since you’re one of the main reasons this is going to happen, and it seems like an obvious existential threat to this whole activity.

  8. wg0

    > Recent events in the field of AI for mathematics have shown us beyond all reasonable doubt that the field is currently undergoing a rapid transformation, unlike anything that we have ever seen before. Language models are solving hard problems which humans could not, and mathematicians are reacting very differently to this news.

    Software I understand but could someone please bring me up to speed what's with Mathematics that it is being disrupted too?

More from this day

2026-10-02