# FCC lets prisons jam contraband phones—even as test jammers blocked 911 calls

Original title: Prisons get OK to jam contraband phones

> Hacker News story 50599313 · language: en · submitted 2026-11-22
> Web version: https://zeli.app/story/50599313
> About this feed: https://zeli.app/llms.txt · Agent guide: https://zeli.app/skill.md

▲ 38 · by [turbocon](<https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=turbocon>) · 💬 80
[original](<https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2026/11/prisons-get-ok-to-jam-contraband-phones-ctia-says-nearby-phones-will-be-jammed-too/>) · [HN discussion](<https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50599313>)

## Summary

The FCC voted to let state and local prisons jam contraband cellphones, a first-ever exception to the agency's ban on non-federal jamming. Chairman Brendan Carr says the tech is now precise enough to stay inside prison walls. But a CTIA pilot with Virginia Tech and South Carolina corrections found the jammers blocked 911 calls, disrupted public safety networks up to two and a half miles away, and still failed to block a large share of targeted calls. Carriers may sue.

## Key quote

> Current jamming technology seems to be both over and underinclusive at once—it risks blocking lawful communications even as it fails to block a significant portion of the targeted contraband device communications.

## HN discussion (80 comments)

### [montroser](<https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50600223>)

> The micro-jamming system blocked 911 calls, interfered with public safety and other communications, and caused interference that impacted wireless network infrastructure up to two and a half miles away.
>
> This doesn't seem especially worth it, if you ask me.  Among the many losers in this deal will be the COs and prison staff, who already have a tough job to begin with.

### [Molitor5901](<https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50600484>)

> I support this but I hope prisons will increase landline redundancy, and greater communications with the rest of the world. Maybe that is using AI to monitor and analyze more, spending more in prisons to rehabilitate better, I'm not sure.. But prisoners, especially violent offenders, should have only controlled access with the world. An un-monitored cell phone..isn't the best thing for inmates to have.

### [wtmt](<https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50601370>)

> The crux of the matter is in the last two paragraphs:
>
> \> There is no way to jam some communications on a spectrum band but not others. That is because radio jammers ‘block all wireless communications on affected spectrum bands,’ and, as the FCC has noted in the past, ‘cannot differentiate between contraband devices and legitimate devices.’”
>
> \> AT&T said that “there is simply no way to limit the reach of jammers to the confines of a given facility. Jammers have been shown to cause interference outside the facilities in which they operate, greatly increasing the risk that someone living or traveling nearby will be impacted.”
>
> We have this problem in India, where jammers are used around prisons and it really affects people who live in the surrounding areas (in a radius of a few kilometers). They cannot use calls or SMS OTPs or the internet or mobile payments reliably. Here’s just one recent news report in the “Silicon Valley of India” (Bengaluru/Bangalore). [1]
>
> [1]: https://www.cnbctv18.com/india/no-calls-poor-internet-delaye...

### [dartharva](<https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50600145>)

> Can someone please educate a non-American why this was a federal issue in the first place? Couldn't counties and their municipal systems themselves decide their planning accordingly?

### [jMyles](<https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50600044>)

> I'm not sure there's anything about today's world we'll look back on with greater astonishment and shame than the fact that we once put human beings in torturous conditions and forced them to work as slaves for our major defense and fast-food corporations, pretextually in response to their having committed some kind of offense to society, although the victims of such offenses (in the cases where one existed at all, which was by no means a sure thing) recouped nothing from this configuration.
>
> That and factory farming; though I don't think that the animals are permitted cell phones either - in some sense, the "ag gag" laws are a sort of "no phoning home from here" rule.

---

## Cite

- Page: https://zeli.app/story/50599313
- Date: 2026-11-22
- Source: arstechnica.com (https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2026/11/prisons-get-ok-to-jam-contraband-phones-ctia-says-nearby-phones-will-be-jammed-too/)
- Hacker News: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50599313

## Other languages

- zh: https://zeli.app/zh/story/50599313 · markdown: https://zeli.app/zh/story/50599313.md
- ja: https://zeli.app/ja/story/50599313 · markdown: https://zeli.app/ja/story/50599313.md
- ko: https://zeli.app/ko/story/50599313 · markdown: https://zeli.app/ko/story/50599313.md
- de: https://zeli.app/de/story/50599313 · markdown: https://zeli.app/de/story/50599313.md
- es: https://zeli.app/es/story/50599313 · markdown: https://zeli.app/es/story/50599313.md
- ru: https://zeli.app/ru/story/50599313 · markdown: https://zeli.app/ru/story/50599313.md
