# Primordial black holes: only a tiny fraction might ever be visible

Original title: If tiny 'primordial' black holes exist

> Hacker News story 50569846 · language: en · submitted 2026-11-20
> Web version: https://zeli.app/story/50569846
> About this feed: https://zeli.app/llms.txt · Agent guide: https://zeli.app/skill.md

▲ 49 · by [wglb](<https://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=wglb>) · 💬 31
[original](<https://phys.org/news/2026-11-tiny-primordial-black-holes.html>) · [HN discussion](<https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50569846>)

## Summary

A phys.org piece explores how tiny primordial black holes — relics of the early universe — could surface in astronomical observations if they exist at all. Hacker News commenters zero in on the cautious wording: the "might show up" framing reads as solid science, while the word "few" implies only an incredibly small percentage of these black holes would ever be detectable.

## Key quote

> The "might show up" part sounds like pretty solid science. Vs. the "few" sounds like it'd be an incredibly small percentage of them.

## HN discussion (31 comments)

### [klez](<https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50598294>)

> My knowledge of physics is rather limited (especially about anything besides Newtonian dynamics), but why would an atom-sized thing, even with the extreme density it has, be disruptive to a star when its mass is still that of an asteroid? I mean, wouldn't it be like a hit from an actual asteroid?
>
> Can someone help me understand why it is different?

### [A_D_E_P_T](<https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50598200>)

> So, to summarize: If an atom-sized, asteroid-mass primordial black hole is trapped by a sunlike star, it will sink to the core, form a swirling accretion disk, and launch magnetic jets that explode the star in a flash of high-energy light detectable by current telescopes.
>
> I had to laugh when I realized that's basically the plot to Stephen Baxter's 1992 novel Timelike Infinity.  In it, future cultists launch a primordial atom-sized black hole into Jupiter, which after some time would force it to explode in a particular high-energy way, with that explosion itself being a message to very distant observers.

### [elvisgodevelop](<https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50598913>)

> An asteroid heats up and dissolves into plasma, whereas a captured primordial black hole can stay inside, keep accreting gas, and grow. Plus, "atom-sized" just refers to the event horizon—its gravity reaches much further out.

### [OroPla](<https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50598471>)

> What does it mean for a black hole to be tiny? Aren't all of them roughly the same size: a tiny little point? Possibly smaller than an atom? I don't have understanding, but to my knowledge the difference between black holes is mass, not size. So if the same little point holds a lot of mass it will have a gravitational pull on things farther away.
>
> Or do we include the gravitational pull when speaking of their size?

### [search_facility](<https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50598071>)

> Interesting article, but this claim:
>
> "Primordial blackholes ... they could represent a significant component of dark matter"
>
> sounds strange. Afaik the problem of DM invisibility is that it is spread around, widely, not concentrated and hidden somewhere.

---

## Cite

- Page: https://zeli.app/story/50569846
- Date: 2026-11-20
- Source: phys.org (https://phys.org/news/2026-11-tiny-primordial-black-holes.html)
- Hacker News: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50569846

## Other languages

- zh: https://zeli.app/zh/story/50569846 · markdown: https://zeli.app/zh/story/50569846.md
- ja: https://zeli.app/ja/story/50569846 · markdown: https://zeli.app/ja/story/50569846.md
- ko: https://zeli.app/ko/story/50569846 · markdown: https://zeli.app/ko/story/50569846.md
- de: https://zeli.app/de/story/50569846 · markdown: https://zeli.app/de/story/50569846.md
- es: https://zeli.app/es/story/50569846 · markdown: https://zeli.app/es/story/50569846.md
- ru: https://zeli.app/ru/story/50569846 · markdown: https://zeli.app/ru/story/50569846.md
