EU Exempts Apple Watch and AirPods from Battery Removal Requirements
The European Commission has adopted new exemptions to its Batteries Regulation, freeing the Apple Watch and AirPods from the requirement to offer user-removable batteries. Citing safety risks related to water resistance and sealed enclosures, the move mirrors previous exemptions for devices like electric toothbrushes. While the iPhone was already exempt, this decision faces further scrutiny from the European Parliament and the Council, sparking debate over e-waste and repair rights.
"I opted instead for a $35 pair of knock-off earbuds, so at least I get 14 years instead of just 2 for the same amount of money now."
HN discussion
- The EU exemption for Apple Watch and AirPods actually applies broadly to all smartwatches and wireless headphones due to size constraints and safety concerns, rather than targeting specific brands.
- Critics argue that non-removable batteries in waterproof devices are a deliberate market strategy to force replacement cycles, as consumers rarely prioritize repairability over performance or price.
- Proponents of the exemption contend that the law's true goal is device longevity, noting that iPhones already meet battery cycle limits and that user-replaceability does not require snap-on convenience but merely the absence of specialist tooling.
- Practitioners warn that opening devices to replace batteries often voids IP68 water resistance ratings, a trade-off manufacturers are unwilling to make for the average consumer.
- Market observers highlight that 'fair' or repairable products like Fairphone 6 remain uncompetitive due to high premiums and inferior performance, suggesting that mandating such features without consumer demand would harm the market.